Essay · updated 23 October 2026
Which pot do you spend first?
Cash, ISAs and pensions are not three versions of the same jar. The order you draw them changes the tax you pay and the risk of selling investments after a fall. There is no universal sequence. There is a short list of frictions worth knowing.
Start with the money whose job is to be spent without drama. Cash held for a year or two of ordinary bills is not an investment. It is there so that a bad quarter in markets does not dictate the weekly shop. Once that buffer exists, arguments about the “optimal” wrapper matter more than they do when the buffer is missing.
ISAs come out clean
Withdrawals from an ISA are not charged income tax. That makes an ISA a flexible way to top up spending without pushing yourself into a higher tax band, and a way to fund the years before pension access. The cost was paid on the way in: no pension-style relief. Spend the ISA too fast, though, and you lose a shelter you cannot easily rebuild once earnings have stopped. The allowance is annual and use-it-or-lose-it. Money taken out can be replaced only within the current rules of the ISA type you hold, which for some flexible ISAs is more generous than people assume, and for others is not. Read the terms of the account you actually have.
Pensions come out mostly as income
After the tax-free amount, pension withdrawals are taxed as income in the year you take them. The familiar tax-free slice is up to 25 per cent, but it is capped by the lump sum allowance of £268,275 for most people, and earlier benefits can already have used part of that allowance. Taking a large slice in one tax year can push the rest of that slice into higher-rate tax. Spreading withdrawals is not a trick. It is how the bands work.
The personal allowance is £12,570. In 2026/27 the full new State Pension uses almost all of it. Before the State Pension starts, some people have unused personal allowance and can draw pension income into that gap. After it starts, the same withdrawal may be taxed from the first pound. Timing is not a footnote.
Flexibly accessing defined-contribution pension income can trigger the money-purchase annual allowance, currently £10,000, which matters if you might still want to contribute. Taking only the tax-free lump sum, without flexible income, is treated differently from moving into flexi-access drawdown and taking income. The paperwork from the provider is the authority, not a memory of a radio phone-in.
A pattern people test, not a rule we issue
A pattern that often gets modelled, and then abandoned if it does not fit, looks like this. Use cash and ISA withdrawals to set the level of spending in the bridge years and to avoid opening the pension before you must. Once the pension is available, draw enough taxable pension income to use allowances without straying into a band you dislike, and let the ISA cover the rest. When the State Pension begins, reduce the taxable withdrawals so the two incomes do not stack higher than you intended. Leave enough invested that a bad sequence of returns does not force the whole plan into cash at the bottom.
Defined-benefit income ignores this pattern. It arrives on the scheme’s terms, often reduced if taken early, and it fills the personal allowance whether you wanted that shape or not. Annuities do something similar: you have exchanged a pot for an income and you no longer choose the year. If either of those is in your life, the ISA becomes the flexible piece, not the pension.
What this essay refuses to do
It will not give you a percentage of the pot to spend. “Four per cent” is a research finding about a particular historic market, a particular mix of assets, and a particular retirement length. It is not a UK tax rule and it is not a promise. Inflation, fees, a longer life than the study assumed, and the moment the State Pension switches on all move the answer.
If you want the order run against your own allowances, that is the work of an adviser or, at minimum, a decent tax-aware cashflow plan. Bring them the spending sketch, the State Pension forecast, and the statements. The order will then be yours, which is the only order that counts.
Continue with the ISA bridge or pension foundations.